CUSTOM COOKIE INQUIRY

Thank you for your interest in ordering Simply Sweet Caroline’s. Custom orders are currently being accepted for November 2023. While I am completed booked for custom orders in September, October, and December 2023, I am planning to have a Halloween Presale, 1989 (Taylor's Version) Flash Sale, Thanksgiving Presale, and Holiday Presale. Join the email list to stay in the loop on launch days!

Custom Sugar Cookie Pricing

Custom sugar cookies start at $65 per dozen and there is a 1 dozen minimum.
Mini custom sugar cookies (1.5-2.5 inches depending on shape) start at $40 per dozen and there is a 2 dozen minimum. Mini cookies are a great addition to any order. Due to the size, they will have less detail than standard sized cookies.
Sets that include extra detailing such as florals or metallics, like gold, silver, rose gold, or copper, will be an additional $10 per dozen. This kind of extra detailing is not able to be used on mini filler cookies.
Simply Small Cookies are mini filler cookies (2 inch circles) in a solid icing color that match one of your custom order's colors. These do not have any detail but are a great addition to your customized sets. Simply Small Cookies are $24 per dozen and there is a 1 dozen minimum.

Please note, I cannot accept any character cookie requests, for example, Paw Patrol, Toy Story, Disney Princesses, Sesame Street, Fortnite, Cocomelon, etc.

Simply Sweet Caroline's is a registered cottage food operation. These products are produced in a home kitchen not inspected by a health department that may also process common food allergens.

First and Last Name

Email Address

Phone Number

If you would like delivery, please provide your address.

Preferred date of pickup or delivery (generally Monday-Friday after 5:30pm or weekends before 10:00am) I'm sorry but I cannot accommodate pickups Monday-Friday before 5:30pm

Please enter the quantity of cookies needed (1 dozen minimum)

Please describe the theme, event type, and desired colors. (1-2 dozen cookies can have between 1-3 colors. 2 dozen+ can have between 1-5 colors)

I love showing the cookie decorating process on social media! If your order is a top secret surprise, please let me know and I will keep these off social media until after your event.