top of page


So Good! So Good! So Good!

Simply Sweet Caroline's is located in the Lakeshore East neighborhood in downtown Chicago and is known for custom decorated sugar cookies, cookie cakes, and seasonal presales.

Custom Sugar Cookie Information and Pricing

  • Custom sugar cookies start at $65 per dozen and there is a 1 dozen minimum. 

  • Mini custom sugar cookies (1.5-2.5 inches depending on shape) start at $40 per dozen and there is a 2 dozen minimum. Mini cookies are a great addition to any order. Due to the size, they will have less detail than standard sized cookies.

  • Simply Small Cookies are mini filler cookies (2 inch circles) in a solid icing color that match one of your custom order's colors. These do not have any detail but are a great addition to your customized sets.  Simply Small Cookies are $24 per dozen and there is a 1 dozen minimum.

  • Sets that include extra detailing such as florals or metallics, like gold, silver, rose gold, or copper, will be an additional $10 per dozen. This kind of extra detailing is not able to be used on 'Simply Small Cookies'.

  • Sugar cookies are a soft vanilla cookie with vanilla royal icing

Custom Cookie Cake Information and Pricing

  • Custom cookie cakes are $35 per cake and serve 8-10 people

  • Cookie cakes are available in two flavors, funfetti sugar cookie or chocolate chip, and both have a soft and smooth vanilla buttercream border. Customers may choose up to 2 colors for the border and for the center message

  • Cookie cakes stay fresh at room temperature for 3 days and can be frozen for up to 3 months

Seasonal Presales

Check out the Holiday Presale page to see current offerings and pricing.

bottom of page