FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
A Cookie Bucket List Theme is a theme I’ve been dying to design and create. I keep a highlight on my Instagram dedicated to completed bucket list themes so you can see the designs and level of detail involved with these sets.
These sets are more detailed than my standard offerings, with at least 8 unique designs per set and typically 6–10 colors.
Pricing:
• $70 per dozen (standard size, 3-4 inch cookies)
When you choose a Bucket List Theme, you’re giving the sugar cookie artist 100% creative freedom. To keep these sets truly creative, I’m unable to accept inspiration photos or additional design requests.
All I need from you is: • Name(s) to include (if applicable) • Age (if applicable) • Event type (e.g., graduation, birthday gift, baby shower, promotion, just because, etc.)
It's a win-win You’ll receive a one-of-a-kind, show-stopping set and I get to bring a long-time creative idea to life.
I am generally booked for custom orders 3-4 weeks in advance. I may be able to accommodate orders with shorter notice though so do reach out! Please note, a "Cookie Crunch fee" will apply for orders with less than 10 days notice, subject to availability. I respond to every inquiry I receive!
All of my starting price points are listed on my website. Please click below to see pricing.
In general, two dozen cookies takes 10 hours minimum. Extra detailing like adding metallics, florals, or watercolor can add anywhere from 45 minutes to 3 hours per dozen! I love sharing the decorating process on Instagram so if you're curious, join us on the Simply Sweet Caroline's page!
Yes! All custom sugar cookies will be individually packaged in a heat sealed cellophane bag.
Want some extra flair?
Sweet Finish: Ribbons, bows, or tags provided by the client can be added to each treat for $1.00 each.
Cookie Couture: Ribbons, bows, or tags sourced by Simply Sweet Caroline's and added to each treat for $1.75+ each.
Yes! We offer custom DIY kits perfect for birthday parties or any event. Our DIY kits include all cookies, icing, and sprinkles to create your masterpiece. To get started, please fill out the custom order form on our website, and we'll be in touch with more information to tailor your order to your specific needs. Whether you're planning a kids' birthday party, a corporate event, or a family gathering, we've got you covered!
Unfortunately I cannot ship cookies.
Yes! Delivery is available starting at $35 within Chicago city limits. Please include your delivery address when submitting your order, and I’ll provide a delivery quote in my response email.
If you’re outside of Chicago, you’re welcome to arrange an Uber Courier (or similar service) to pick up your order during a designated pickup window.
All cookies are heat sealed individually. They will stay fresh in their heat sealed bag at room temperature for 3 weeks. Please do not place in the refrigerator. They can also be frozen for several months.
Cookie cakes stay fresh at room temperature for 3 days or can be placed in the refrigerator for 5 days. Cookie cakes can be frozen for 3 months.
I am a part time baker and am only one person making each individual cookie so I do not offer bulk discounts. Each cookie takes as long as the next one, even in bulk.
I‘m sorry but I cannot accept character themes/designs. For example, Disney Princesses, Sesame Street, Toy Story, Cocomelon, Pokémon, Paw Patrol, Fortnite, etc.
At this time, I’m unable to accommodate special dietary requests or allergy-friendly orders. All cookies are made in a kitchen with shared equipment, and I cannot guarantee that products are free from allergens or cross-contact.